3.12.1.4
Thomson's experiment revealed the electron as a universal subatomic particle
Turning Points in Physics | AQA A-Level Physics
What Thomson measured
- J.J. Thomson used the crossed-fields method to measure the specific chargeThe charge-to-mass ratio of a particle, $e/m_e$, measured in C kg$^{-1}$. of cathode rays.
- He found a value of approximately $1.76 \times 10^{11}$ C kg$^{-1}$.
- The key part is the comparison: the specific charge of a hydrogen ion (the smallest known charged particle at the time) is $9.58 \times 10^{7}$ C kg$^{-1}$.
- The electron's specific charge is therefore about 1800 times larger than that of the hydrogen ion.
Why this was significant
- Since the electron and the hydrogen ion carry the same magnitude of charge ($e$), the only way the electron's specific charge could be 1800 times larger is if its mass is 1800 times smaller.
- This meant the electron was far lighter than any atom, proving that atoms are not indivisible. There must be particles smaller than atoms.
- Thomson found the same specific charge regardless of what gas was in the discharge tube or what metal was used for the cathode.
- This universality showed that the electron is a fundamental constituent of all matter, not something unique to a particular element.
Limitations of the experiment
- Thomson could only measure $e/m_e$, not $e$ or $m_e$ individually. It took Millikan's oil drop experiment (1909) to measure $e$ on its own.
- Once $e$ was known, $m_e$ could be calculated: $m_e = e \,/\, (e/m_e) = 9.11 \times 10^{-31}$ kg.
Common Mistake
Students sometimes say Thomson "discovered the electron's charge." He did not. He measured the specific charge $e/m_e$. Millikan later measured $e$ independently. Make sure you distinguish between these two experiments.